Friday, September 23, 2016

Discussion of Metacognition, Problem Solving, and Comprehension

Dr. Lauren Barth-Cohen

Imagine you are going to advise a K-8 school on a new math curriculum that focuses on problem solving.  Take what you know from the readings to advise the school.  What should be their learning objects?  What should they look for in new curricular materials to help achieve those objectives?

Something that really struck a cord for me in the the reading (Gredler, p. 232) was the study discussed third to fifth grade student error detection in "more than" & "less than" mathematical word problems.  Gredler makes a brilliant yet possible over-looked concept once one gets to involve in the academic analysis of learners (I believe at every level - not simply young ones):

     "One reason for the lack of identification of unsolvable problems is that children develop a "WORD PROBLEM" SCHEMA in which WORD PROBLEMS are DIVORCED from REAL-WORLD problems (emphasis added by me).

I believe this is one of the core reasons (not to mention student-owned cliches) learning simple doesn't happen.

I've studied the teaching methods of Maria Montessori (Links to an external site.) in order to better understand the young men I taught in Rabigh, KSA.  It was a vocational school in a remote village.  Much of the teaching was done by text book or making wonderful, high-end Lenovo tablets into shiny e-readers or pretty platforms for engineering Philippino professor's pirated PowerPoints.  They had wonderful equipment - conduits, pumps, operations boards & instrumentation panels - but the students were asked to solve word problems on paper for the majority of their two year program.

With that said, I've never been able to understand why anyone would study or learn math - except for those few who enjoy it.  I know it does appeal to some - and that's absolutely fabulous.

From my experience of learning math in high school &/or hacking it or completely avoiding it wherever else possible, I would advise that a new curriculum be made virtual . . . though not necessarily virtual reality.

Montessori believed that students learned best by real world doing, touching, smelling & listening.  The schools that are her namesake produce some of the finest young minds today - including Larry Page & Sergey Brin, the founders of Google.  I believe metacognition - thinking about thinking - happens when the learner is thinking about she is doing.  The need to remember becomes more "real" when the learner is in the act of doing something very real, & possibly failing at it.

I think math curricula should include much more touchy-feely stuff, like a Montessori (Links to an external site.) school or a vocational school.  If there's a problem with how many buses would be needed for so many soldiers - rather than giving young learners an option of a remainder - materials in a virtual world (possibly something in the WolframAlpha (Links to an external site.) persuasion) could be manipulated by the students to understand the real world relation that is so vital for true learning & the long-term retaining of knowledge.

Montessori Method

Want to give the students a problem about cookies?  Use real cookies - or Skittles.

I certainly realize that my approach has real-world financial limitations.  It could be expensive.  In the best of all possible schools, I would make those suggestions.


Discussion of Behaviorism

Dr. Lauren Barth-Cohen

Describe a teaching and learning situation from your experience in which you think behaviorism applies. What inputs trigger the behavior?  What are the results?  Critique your example, what aspects of the teaching and learning situation are not explained by a behaviorist approach? 

Sep 1, 2016 Sep 1 at 7:50am

Prior to doing the reading, I penned this last week.  It's raw but I believe illustrative of commonly practiced behaviorism.  The first example involved "learning" by punishment of yours truly when I was a young Army recruit at Ft. Leonard Wood.  The second was my application of a reward for a conditioned response, volunteerism, as I began teaching English to university students in Changzhou, China.  I'll bullet the negative (NEG) & positive (POS) experiences under their respective sections.

Learning/teaching situation

NEG - As initial entry training (IET) privates, young soldiers were not allowed to smoke.

POS - As a new teacher in China, I found it difficult to persuade intimidated college freshmen to raise their hands & speak.

Triggers

NEG - Severe penalties, including physical fitness punishments (like hundreds of push ups, of course) were given to privates violating the no-smoking regulations.  As a cocky & careless young GI, I was caught smoking.  On a frigid, snowy Missouri evening in January, for my punishment I was required to move a yards of firewood - stacked three to four feet high - from one side of the long barracks building to other.  I worked from around five in the evening until I collapsed just after midnight.

POS - As prompted by one of the veteran English-as-a-Second-Language (ESL) teachers at the Changzhou Textile Garment Institute of University City, I offered Hershey's Kisses (authentic American chocolates being a rare & expensive treat in the People's Republic of China!) for students' contributions - one chocolate for simply raising their hands; two for using full sentences; & three Kisses for English that was laughable (hopefully correct), entertaining and/or profound enough to spur additional students' responses.

Results

NEG - Very few soldiers were caught sneaking a cigarette - regardless of how many some of our drill instructors smoked.  After witnessing my punishment - fellow recruits were able to see my labor of shame from the warmth of the barracks bay window - young soldiers were even more surreptitious of their own smoking habits.  I was never caught smoking again.  What do you know?!  It worked.

POS - After the initial blushing & feigned indignance, Chinese college kids engaged in more hand-raising; students tried to surpass simple one-word answers & build complete, grammatical sentences in response to my questions; public speaking fear was reduced; & the practice created an environment of friendly competition & playful English retorts.

Critique

NEG - The Non-commissioned officers (NCOs) doling out these punishments have no idea what's going on in the young recruits' minds.  Perhaps the soldier being punished might be thinking, "Hmm, I really deserve this.  Must be more disciplined . . . somehow!"  Or, just maybe, the shamed recruit might be planning a way to get even with this old guy, or the whole Army, for such unjust treatment somewhere down the long dirty road.  Yes, in my case, the unwanted behavior was curbed.  It certainly wasn't permanent & only increased my guarded-ness of the prohibited habit.  I'm not sure it would work at all on some of the "thicker," stubborn young soldiers with which I have had the pleasure of serving.


POS - Of course, I really had no idea what was going on in these Chinese kids minds.  Was I truly embarrassing them but their weakness for chocolate overcame their shame of accepting candy from a veritable stranger?  If I suddenly ran out of chocolates, would students cease the behavior (when I inevitably did, I would promise to bring more next time - which didn't always happen)?  And then, it didn't work on all students.  Some students had no desire for the chocolates & appeared to snub other freshmen for behaving immaturely - performing tricks for food.

Changzhou Textile Garment Institute - September 2007, Changzhou, People's Republic of China